other US Catholic Dioceses
and Religious Orders That Have Filed for Bankruptcy
Protection due to expenses incurred defending child sexual abuse claims
3/31/17, "Montana Diocese Seeks Chapter 11 Protection to Address Abuse Claims," Wall St. Journal, Tom Corrigan (subscrip)
diocese becomes 17th U.S. diocese or religious order to seek
bankruptcy-court protection while facing litigation over sexual-abuse
"The Roman Catholic Diocese of Great Falls-Billings, Mont., filed for
bankruptcy protection Friday, becoming the 17th in a growing number of
troubled Catholic dioceses and religious orders to turn to chapter 11.
diocese’s bankruptcy filing comes in the face of 72 lawsuits claiming
child sexual abuse by priests and other diocesan staff. More claims may
be filed as the case goes through the bankruptcy process.
Falls-Billings Bishop Michael Warfel told The Wall Street Journal he has
already met with several sexual abuse victims and is open to meeting
with all of them.
lot of people have carried wounds for many years, and I am very
sensitive to that,” he said Friday. “It’s really important in the
healing process for victims to meet with the bishop and the diocese, and
I encourage it.”
All diocesan bankruptcies to date—from the
Archdiocese of Portland, Ore., in 2004 to the Diocese of New Ulm, Minn.,
which filed in March—have been driven by mounting liabilities tied to
the past sexual abuse of minors.
Filing for bankruptcy offers
the diocese immediate protection from all pending and future lawsuits,
giving it breathing room to continue its ministry while it finalizes a
plan to compensate victims.
“On behalf of the entire Diocese of
Great Falls-Billings, I express my profound sorrow and sincere apologies
to anyone who was abused by a priest, a sister or a lay Church worker,”
the bishop said in a statement Friday. “No child should experience harm
from anyone who serves the Church.”
Bishop Warfel added that no
priests from his diocese facing credible accusations of abuse are in
active ministry and that most are deceased. The vast majority of abuse
allegations involving the Catholic Church in the U.S. occurred decades
The Diocese of Great Falls-Billings covers nearly two thirds
of the state of Montana, but serves a relatively small population.
According to its website, the diocese has about 40,000 parishioners, 42
active priests, 50 parishes and 50 missions.
In bankruptcy court
papers, the diocese listed total assets of about $21 million. The
diocese’s parishes aren’t separately incorporated, and it isn’t clear
how much, if any, of their assets will be included in a future
The Great Falls-Billings diocese enters
bankruptcy with a negotiated agreement with both victims plaintiffs and
its insurance carriers, which aims to help speed up the chapter 11 case.
The agreement, reached with the help of a mediator, provides a road map
intended to avoid legal obstacles at the outset of the case, according
to Ford Elsaesser, a lawyer for the diocese.
Elsaesser says he expects the case to follow in the footsteps of the
Diocese of Helena, Mont., a neighboring diocese that sought bankruptcy
protection in 2014.
The Diocese of Helena eventually reached a $21 million settlement with
about 380 victims, largely through out-of-court negotiations. The
diocese spent just over a year in chapter 11 but less than five hours in
court, according to Mr. Elsaesser, who also represented the Helena
Other U.S. diocesan bankruptcies, however, have been protracted and hard-fought, with many stretching out over several years.
Archdiocese of Milwaukee’s bankruptcy lasted nearly five years, and a
dispute over access to assets reached the U.S. Supreme Court before it was settled. And the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis, now in its third year of chapter 11, has been unable to reconcile with victims and the two sides are moving forward with competing—and starkly different—compensation plans.
everyone agrees that bankruptcy is the best forum for handling
sensitive allegations of past sexual abuse. Critics say the process can
deprive victims of the opportunity to present their stories to a jury
and can force other victims to come forward before they are ready. Once a
bankruptcy comes to a close, victims whose claims stem from abuse that
occurred prior to the bankruptcy are typically barred from taking their
allegations to court.
“While we had hoped to obtain justice for
our clients at trial, we are hopeful that the diocese’s bankruptcy will
result in nonmonetary terms for the protection of children and monetary
recognition of the tragedies endured by victims,” Leander James, an
attorney for a group of victims, said in a statement Friday."
16 other US Catholic organizations that have filed for bankruptcy since 2004 due to expenses, 14 dioceses plus two Catholic groups, Oregon
Province of the Jesuits (2/17/09), Congregation
of the Christian Brothers (4/28/11):
and Religious Orders That Have Filed for Bankruptcy Protection," Bankruptcy
Protection in the Abuse Crisis, bishopaccountability.org
1. Archdiocese of Portland OR
of Tucson AZ (9/20/04)
of Spokane WA (12/6/04)
of Davenport IA (10/10/06)
of San Diego CA (2/27/07)
of Fairbanks AK (3/1/08)
Province of the Jesuits (2/17/09)
of Wilmington DE and MD (10/18/09)
of Milwaukee WI (1/4/11)
of the Christian Brothers (4/28/11)
9. Diocese of Gallup NM (11/12/13)
10. Diocese of Stockton CA (1/15/14)
11. Diocese of Helena MT (1/31/14)
12. Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis MN (1/16/15)
13. Archdiocese of Milwaukee a proposed settlement was announced (8/4/15)
14. Diocese of Duluth MN (12/7/15)
Saturday, April 1, 2017
Catholic diocese in Montana becomes 17th in US to file for bankruptcy due to expenses of defending child sexual abuse claims. 'Filing for bankruptcy offers diocese immediate protection from all pending and future lawsuits, giving it breathing room to continue its ministry'-Wall St. Journal
Posted by susan at 11:49 PM